Protect What Matters Most 

With Coverage You Can Trust.

For over 50 years, McGahey Insurance has provided personal, commercial, and residential insurance solutions backed by local expertise and genuine care.

Auto Insurance

Smart Coverage for North Grenville Drivers

Driving here means winter commutes, rural roads, and unique local risks. Our licensed brokers specialize in policies that ensure maximum protection without overpaying.

It only takes a few minutes to find out how much you can save without sacrificing coverage. Connect with our North Grenville office today.

Automobile Solutions

Personal

Your policy is precisely tailored to your vehicle and driving habits. We simplify the coverage so you know exactly what is protected.

Commercial

Your vehicles are critical to your operation, whether it is for trades or services. We will design a policy that protects all your commercial auto needs.

Collector

We recognize the unique investment of a specialty vehicle. We provide policies that cover your classic or modern performance car up to its full appraised value.

Recreational

Protect your investment and enjoy your time off. Our licensed brokers provide the clear coverage you need for ATVs, snowmobiles, trailers, and boats.

How McGahey Protects You On the Road

For over 50 years, McGahey has protected what matters most to the families and businesses of the North Grenville community.

Expert Auto Advice

RIBO licensed professionals ensure accurate, transparent policy details.

More Options, Better Rates

We shop the market on your behalf for the best competitive price.

Local Service for Fast Claims

Speak to a real person in our local office, never an automated phone tree.

How to Select Auto Insurance

Some auto insurance coverage is mandatory, and some is optional. Know the difference before you buy. Because we are independent brokers, we shop the leading insurance companies to find you the best value and the right fit.

Mandatory Coverage

Liability & mandatory coverage

Ontario law requires drivers to have enough coverage to protect you financially against major risks and legal claims.

Types of coverage:

Additional Protection

Loss & damage protection (optional)

Coverage to repair or replace your car after collisions, theft, or weather damage.

Types of coverage:

Custom Add-ons

Enhanced options & endorsements (optional)

Customize your policy to suit your lifestyle. Add extra layers of security and convenience to your standard policy.

Types of coverage:

Secure Your Livelihood with Local Experts

Whether you are renewing a policy or starting fresh, our brokers provide the honest advice and reliable options you deserve.